Insulated clothing: Down vs Synthetic
When gearing up for cold weather adventures, choosing the right insulation in your clothing can make all the difference. In the world of insulated outerwear, there are two main types of insulation, down and synthetic, each with its unique advantages. Let’s dive into the details of down and synthetic insulation and explore how to stay warm during winter excursions.
Different types of insulation
Down, with its unrivaled warmth-to-weight ratio, has long been the favorite for those seeking lightweight warmth. On the other hand, synthetic insulation offers reliable performance even in wet conditions, making it a go-to choice for adventurers who face unpredictable weather. Let’s break down the pros and cons of each to help you choose the best option for your cold-weather activities.
Down insulation
Down insulation comes from the fluffy feathers under the bellies of ducks and geese, and it's fantastic at keeping you warm without adding much weight. This makes it great when you are out in dry, chilly weather and don’t want heavy gear. Down traps warm air really well, helping you stay toasty.
However, down isn’t as good when it gets wet—it clumps up and loses its ability to hold warm air efficiently. If you’re in damp or humid places, down might not be the best choice unless you pair it with a waterproof jacket to keep its fluffiness and warmth.
Pros
Excellent warmth-to-weight ratio, making it extremely lightweight and warm.
Compresses very well, making it easy to pack without taking up much space.
Cons
Loses its insulating properties when wet and takes a long time to dry.
Requires special care when washing and drying to maintain its insulating properties.
Synthetic insulation
Synthetic insulation is made from man-made fibers that mimic the way down trap heat. It also remains effective when wet, making it ideal for activities in moist or unpredictable weather. It's also quicker to dry and generally more durable than down, handling wear and tear better over time.
Synthetic insulation is also hypoallergenic, making it a great choice for anyone allergic to down. It's perfect for wet climates and activities where you might get a bit more exposure to water, like snowboarding or hiking in areas with frequent rain.
Pros
Retains warmth even when wet, making it suitable for damp or rainy conditions.
Dries much faster than down, which is beneficial in wet climates.
Hypoallergenic, making it a better choice for those with allergies.
Easier to care for than down.
Cons
Heavier than down, which might be a drawback for activities where weight is a critical factor.
Does not compress as tightly as down, requiring more pack space.
How warm is the insulated jacket?
Down typically offers a higher warmth-to-weight ratio than synthetic insulation, making it lighter yet warmer for its weight. To gauge a jacket's warmth, consider its fill weight. For down jackets, also look at the fill power, which indicates how fluffy the down is and how well it traps heat.
What is fill weight?
Fill weight measures the amount of insulation used within a jacket and varies by the type of insulation. For down, fill weight is usually given in grams and reflects the total amount of down used. It is often assessed alongside fill power, which measures the loft and efficiency of the down. For synthetic insulation, fill weight is expressed in grams per square meter (g/m2), denoting the density of the insulation and correlating directly to its thickness and warmth.
What is fill power?
This measures the loft or fluffiness of the down used in the jacket, indicating its quality. Higher fill power means the down can trap more air for its weight, providing better insulation while being lighter. Fill power typically ranges from about 500 to 900 cubic inches per ounce (CUIN). Jackets with higher fill power are usually warmer for their weight.
Design features also affect the warmth of the jacket
While the type and amount of insulation are key in determining a jacket's warmth, its design is also important for heat retention. A well-crafted jacket features smart design elements that help keep warm air close to your body and reduce heat loss, ensuring you stay warm and cozy even on colder days.
Outer material: The jacket's outer material is essential for blocking wind and repelling water, both of which can dramatically reduce a jacket's warmth. A jacket featuring a wind- and waterproof membrane can help you keep warm, especially in wet and windy conditions.
Zipper guards: Zippers can be weak points for heat loss. Jackets with zipper garages and storm flaps behind and over zippers help seal warmth and block out the cold.
Adjustable features: Features like cinchable hoods, adjustable cuffs, and drawcord hems allow the wearer to tighten the jacket at critical points, trapping warm air and preventing drafts.
Fit and layering space: The jacket should allow for layering underneath without being too loose. A too tight jacket may restrict movement and reduce the insulating properties of the layers beneath by compressing them, while one that is too loose might let warm air escape.
